This article contains affiliate links: if you buy through them we may earn a commission, at no extra cost to you. Read our affiliate disclosure.
It’s the seventh inning, and the pitcher’s fastball suddenly feels like throwing through mud. Or it’s a swimmer on her fourth set of the morning, wincing every time her hand enters the water; or a lifter who notices that reaching for the bar overhead now brings a deep ache. Shoulders are built to move in almost every direction, and athletes ask a lot of them. Shoulder injuries are problems with the bones, joint, ligaments, tendons or muscles around the shoulder, and the two that come up most in sport are rotator cuff problems (the tendons that hold the arm in the socket) and instability (a shoulder that slips or comes out of the socket).
Quick answer: Rotator cuff problems are usually an irritated or torn tendon, with pain when lifting the arm, reaching overhead or lying on that side. Instability means the shoulder partly or fully slips out of its socket. See a clinician (a sports medicine doctor, orthopaedic specialist or physical therapist) for shoulder pain that lasts, weakness, a shoulder that gives way, or any dislocation, which should be treated as an emergency.
When to get urgent medical help
Some shoulder problems cannot wait. Get urgent or emergency care for:
- A possible dislocation. The American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) OrthoInfo says a dislocated shoulder should be treated as an emergency. Signs include visible deformity, swelling, bruising, severe pain, numbness and weakness. Do not try to pop it back in yourself.
- Signs that a nerve or blood vessel may be hurt. OrthoInfo lists a cool hand that looks white or purple as a sign of artery injury, and numbness or being unable to move the shoulder or arm as signs of nerve injury. MedlinePlus also says to call your provider if the arm or hand turns purple or you develop a fever after a dislocation.
- A sudden injury with a snap or pop and immediate weakness. OrthoInfo describes sudden rotator cuff tears as often causing intense pain, a snapping sensation and immediate weakness. Get checked promptly, and do not keep playing.
- Shoulder, arm or upper-body discomfort with chest symptoms. The CDC lists pain or discomfort in one or both arms or shoulders among the symptoms of a heart attack, along with chest discomfort, shortness of breath, nausea and feeling faint. The CDC says to call 9-1-1 right away if you notice heart attack symptoms in yourself or someone else, and MedlinePlus adds to call even if you are not sure.
What the shoulder is and why it gets hurt
MedlinePlus describes the shoulder as the body’s most movable joint, made of three bones (the collarbone, shoulder blade and upper arm bone) held in place by muscles, tendons and ligaments.
Rotator cuff problems
The rotator cuff is four tendons that hold the arm in the shoulder socket and help lift and rotate it. According to OrthoInfo, a tear happens when one or more of them partly or fully detaches from the upper arm bone; most tears involve the supraspinatus tendon, and nearly 2 million people in the US visit a doctor for rotator cuff tears each year. MedlinePlus describes the broader group of rotator cuff injuries as tendinitis (irritated, swollen tendons), bursitis (a swollen fluid-filled sac) and tears, which may be partial or full-thickness.
OrthoInfo describes two main routes. A sudden (acute) tear usually follows a fall on an outstretched arm or lifting something heavy with a jerking motion. A gradual (degenerative) tear is the more common cause and builds up through repeated stress and age-related wear, often with little pain.
Instability and dislocation
OrthoInfo defines a complete dislocation as the joint surfaces fully separating, and a partial dislocation, called a subluxation, as them separating only partly. Most dislocations come from trauma such as a fall, and the shoulder usually slips forward, often when the arm is raised. People with naturally loose ligaments and people who have already dislocated once are at higher risk. When the ligaments, tendons and muscles become loose or torn so that the arm repeatedly fails to stay centered, OrthoInfo calls it chronic shoulder instability. It also says repetitive overhead motion can stretch the ligaments over time.
Who gets shoulder injuries and in which sports
For rotator cuff tears, OrthoInfo names people over 40, workers who lift or reach overhead (it mentions painters and carpenters), and athletes, especially tennis players and baseball pitchers. Tears are more common in the dominant arm, and OrthoInfo notes that most tears in young adults result from a traumatic injury. For rotator cuff tendinitis and impingement, OrthoInfo points to young athletes who use their arms overhead, including swimmers, baseball, tennis and volleyball players. For instability, it lists swimming, tennis and volleyball as sports where repetitive overhead motion can stretch the ligaments.
Throwing sports get their own OrthoInfo page. It explains that repeated high-speed overhead throwing stresses the structures that keep the ball of the joint centered, with the late cocking and follow-through phases putting the greatest forces on the shoulder. Sport pages on this site with their own injury guides include baseball (injuries), softball (injuries), swimming (injuries), water polo (injuries), tennis (injuries), volleyball (injuries), handball (injuries), rugby (injuries), football (injuries), wrestling (injuries), gymnastics (injuries), weightlifting (injuries) and CrossFit (injuries).
Signs and symptoms
For a rotator cuff problem, OrthoInfo and MedlinePlus list these signs:
- Pain at the front or side of the shoulder, or in the upper arm, often worse at night and when lying on the affected shoulder.
- Pain or stiffness when lifting or lowering the arm, reaching overhead or reaching behind the back. In overhead sports, OrthoInfo says pain can show up during throwing, spiking or serving.
- Arm weakness, and a crackling or clicking feeling with certain movements.
- No pain at all in some cases. Both sources note that some tears are painless, which is one reason weakness is worth taking seriously.
For instability, OrthoInfo lists repeated dislocations, repeated episodes of the shoulder giving out, and a persistent feeling of looseness or slipping. Partial dislocations can be hard to notice because the joint may slide back on its own. For throwers, OrthoInfo says an early sign of instability can be pain and a loss of throwing speed, and some throwers feel the arm “go dead.”
What usually happens next in care
This is a general outline from the sources, not a diagnosis or a plan for any one person. A clinician usually starts with your history and a physical exam, including strength and circulation and nerve checks after a dislocation. OrthoInfo says X-rays can rule out other causes such as arthritis and confirm a dislocation, while MRI or ultrasound can show the soft tissues and the size and location of a tear.
For rotator cuff problems, OrthoInfo says treatment often starts without surgery: rest and activity changes, anti-inflammatory medicines, physical therapy and sometimes a steroid injection. It reports that about 80 to 85% of people with rotator cuff tears get pain relief and better function this way. Surgery is usually considered when pain continues despite that care, or for active people and those who do overhead work or sports; OrthoInfo lists symptoms lasting 6 to 12 months, a tear larger than 3 cm, significant weakness, or a recent acute injury as indicators.
For a dislocation, OrthoInfo describes the usual first step as reduction (a clinician returns the joint to its position, usually in an emergency room), then a sling until follow-up, followed by physical therapy to restore motion and strength. MedlinePlus says to see an orthopaedic specialist within about a week after the shoulder is put back, and notes each dislocation can make the shoulder easier to dislocate again. OrthoInfo says surgery is considered if dislocations recur, if the joint cannot be reduced, or if there is muscle or bone damage, and may also be considered after a first dislocation in some young athletes. Which path fits is a decision for you and your clinician.
Prevention and lowering your risk
No exercise or habit guarantees a healthy shoulder, but a few measures have support:
- Conditioning, technique and rest. OrthoInfo’s page on throwing athletes lists proper conditioning, technique and rest periods, stretching, and strengthening of the upper back and core as ways to maintain shoulder function, and cites pitch count limits and rest recommendations to protect young throwers.
- Exercise-based programs. A 2024 meta-analysis in the Journal of Athletic Training (Naderi and colleagues) found that exercise-based injury-prevention programs appear to reduce the risk of shoulder injuries in team handball players (pooled odds ratio 0.60). A 2024 systematic review of 8 studies in throwing athletes (Moiroux-Sahraoui and colleagues) suggested that core stability and lower-limb strengthening can reduce excess stress on the shoulder. These are research findings in particular groups, not promises for every athlete.
- Do not play through pain, and ask before exercising. OrthoInfo advises talking to a doctor or physical therapist before shoulder exercises, as some may not be safe for you. OrthoInfo says avoiding activities that cause pain helps. MedlinePlus says early treatment can keep mild rotator cuff injuries from becoming more serious later on.
Returning to play
A qualified clinician, such as a sports medicine doctor, orthopaedic specialist or physical therapist, decides when it is safe to return, and the answer depends on the injury, the treatment and the sport. OrthoInfo describes the general principle for throwers: a doctor or physical therapist directs a gradual return to throwing, and after surgery a sling is typically used for a short period, flexibility work comes first, and strengthening usually starts about 4 to 6 weeks after surgery. For throwers with shoulder injuries, OrthoInfo says complete pain relief typically takes 2 to 4 months and return to sport may take up to a year or more. Those are published ranges for that group, not a timetable for you.
Young athletes, and athletes over 40
For young throwers, OrthoInfo recommends pitch count limits and rest. The American Academy of Pediatrics’ policy statement on baseball and softball injuries (Pediatrics, 2012) stresses that parents, coaches and players should learn the early warning signs of elbow and shoulder overuse. For older athletes, OrthoInfo says age-related wear is the most common cause of rotator cuff tears and that people over 40 are more likely to be affected, and that a degenerative tear in one shoulder raises the chance of a tear in the other.
Gear that may help with training and soreness
Gear does not treat or fix a shoulder injury, and no product here replaces an exam. If a physical therapist gives you shoulder exercises, many are done with light resistance bands, and the colour-coded bands used in clinics are sold for home use. A small massage gun is something some athletes use on sore muscles around the shoulder; ask your clinician before using any device near an injured joint. More options are in our resistance bands guide and massage gun guide.

THERABAND Beginner Kit
- Yellow, red, green flat bands
- Clinic-standard color system
- Latex (non-latex kit sold too)
$11.99 at Amazon, as of Nov 17, 2026 01:07 UTC
Check price on Amazon
Theragun Mini (3rd Gen)
- Pocket size, 3 speeds
- 3 attachments
- Travel lock
$219.99 at Amazon, as of Nov 17, 2026 01:07 UTC
Check price on AmazonShoulder injury FAQs
How do I know if it’s my rotator cuff?
You can’t tell from the outside. Pain when lifting or lowering the arm, night pain, pain lying on that side and weakness are common signs according to OrthoInfo and MedlinePlus, but other shoulder problems can feel similar. A clinician uses an exam and sometimes X-ray, ultrasound or MRI to find out.
Can a rotator cuff tear heal without surgery?
OrthoInfo says about 80 to 85% of people with rotator cuff tears get pain relief and better function from nonsurgical treatment, but it also says tears can get bigger over time, and surgery is considered in some cases. Whether it applies to you depends on the tear, your activity and your clinician’s advice.
My shoulder popped out and went back in on its own. Do I still need to be seen?
Yes, it’s worth getting checked. OrthoInfo explains that a partial dislocation (subluxation) can slide back by itself and look fairly normal while still being a real injury, and that a prior dislocation raises the risk of further ones, even without a new injury.
Can I keep playing with a sore shoulder?
If a certain activity bothers your shoulder, MedlinePlus advises stopping it and checking with a provider. OrthoInfo warns that rotator cuff tears can enlarge with continued use despite pain. If the pain keeps coming back, or there is weakness, see a clinician before you push on.
Should my child see a doctor for shoulder pain after pitching or swimming?
Pain that returns, pain with throwing, or any weakness is a reason to see a pediatrician or sports medicine doctor. The AAP says parents, coaches and players should know the early warning signs of shoulder and elbow overuse.
Is shoulder pain always a shoulder problem?
Not always. The CDC lists pain or discomfort in the arms or shoulders as a possible heart attack symptom, usually together with chest discomfort or shortness of breath. If that combination appears, call 9-1-1.
Sources
- OrthoInfo (AAOS): Rotator Cuff Tears
- OrthoInfo (AAOS): Shoulder Dislocation
- OrthoInfo (AAOS): Chronic Shoulder Instability and Dislocation
- OrthoInfo (AAOS): Shoulder Impingement/Rotator Cuff Tendinitis
- OrthoInfo (AAOS): Shoulder Injuries in the Throwing Athlete
- MedlinePlus: Rotator Cuff Injuries
- MedlinePlus: Shoulder Injuries and Disorders
- MedlinePlus: Dislocated shoulder – aftercare
- CDC: Heart Attack Symptoms
- Naderi et al., J Athl Train 2024: exercise-based injury prevention in team handball (PubMed)
- Moiroux-Sahraoui et al., Diagnostics 2024: prevention of overhead shoulder injuries in throwing athletes (PubMed)
- American Academy of Pediatrics: Policy statement on baseball and softball, Pediatrics 2012
General information for education only, not medical advice. It does not diagnose or treat any condition and cannot replace an exam by a qualified clinician. If you are hurt, see a sports medicine doctor, orthopaedic specialist or physical therapist, and call emergency services for danger signs. Read how we work in our editorial policy, and find more in Injuries & Joint Health.
